Conservatives – and humans with any sense of history or moral conscience – have been blasting CBS’s Margaret Brennan for blaming the Holocause on “free speech”.
Seems pretty indefensible.
Now, some do indeed try to defend Brennan. One such argument points to the fact that the Nazis did co-opt free speech. In an editorial in 1928, Joseph Göbbels, Hitler’s social media director, wrote, “We are an anti-parliamentarian party that for good reasons rejects the Weimar constitution and its republican institutions . . . We enter the Reichstag to arm ourselves with democracy’s weapons. If democracy is foolish enough to give us free railway passes and salaries, that is its problem. It does not concern us. Any way of bringing about the revolution is fine by us.”
So yes. The Nazis co-opted free speech. to gain power. .
They also co-opted many of the other institutions of German society – the Lutheran and Catholic churches, the school system, academia (Hitler’s inner circle was disproportionately artists, writers and intelledtuals, not thugs), the bureaucracy (in effect a fourth branch of government), and eventually the military, as well the quirks of the structure of German government under the Bismarck constitution (which the Weimar constitution didn’t change much, other than replacing the Kaiser with an elected President).
So it’s not a very good defense of Brennan.
So let’s make sure we’re clear on *why* this exchange happened.
- VP Vance loudly and rightly castigated Europe for curtailing free speech – arresting people for social media posts, confiscating computers, etc.
- Brennan tried to press Rubio, “You’re standing in a country where free speech was weaponized to commit a genocide”. Brennan was saying because the Weimar version of “free speech” was one of the *many* factors the Nazis (as you cite with Göbbels) were able to use to gain power, the Germans and Brits are *right* to curtail free speech [1].
In some ways, it’s the “why was your skirt too short?” argument.
In others, it’s much more sinister than that.
Remember – Big Left’s house PR firms have been strongly hinting that free speech is just too complicated and dangerous for us proles. Harris and Walz *ran on* curtailing free speech, including reinforcing the (very Göbbelsian) alliance between the DOJ and Big Tech. Governor Walz, who is in many ways the exposed “id” of today’s center-left, established a database to track “badthink” in Minnesota.
The system of which Brennan is a privileged part isn’t even being coy about it. They think free speech (for the rabble) is a bad thing, and they act on that belief.
Rubio pointed out, absolutely correctly, that it wasn’t peoples’ right to speak freely, but *a government with too much power*, that committed genocide. No need for an apology – it’s true.
Brennan is literally everything that’s wrong with today’s news media. I will be standing on Fifth Avenue pelting her with (rhetorical) rocks and garbage as security escorts her out of Black Rock when she’s eventually laid off, on her way to her inevitable job at NPR or “The View”.
[1 Well, *some* peoples’ free speech, anyway.