Without a Kluwe

The foot of the Minnesota Vikings’ punter will no longer be in his mouth.

Chris Kluwe: so focused on his job

There is a truism in all professional life that your cost, real or perceived, cannot outweigh your value.  Once that threshold is crossed, there is often little incentive for an employer to maintain such an employee.

Of course, that truism seems to take an extraordinary beating when it comes to being applied in the world of professional sports.  Athletes are excused all manner of crimes and statements while staying employed.  Kobe Bryant hardly suffered despite allegations of rape.  Michael Vick emerged from jail for the cruel practice of dog fighting and resumed his NFL career.  Mike Tyson’s been in and out of jail three times.  If he goes back a forth time, apparently it’s free.

Chris Kluwe: so totally focused on his job

In that light, the Minnesota Vikings’ expected release of outspoken punter/gay-marriage advocate/musician/video-game enthusiast/Deadspin contributor/gameboard store owner/all-around stunted adolescent Chris Kluwe hardly seems fair.  Kluwe has maintained a decent-to-high punting yards average since joining the NFL (notwithstanding his drop to 22nd in the NFL in 2012). And in a league that doesn’t even have a punter in their Hall of Fame (another source of Kluwe-influenced controversy), Kluwe may be the most relatively famous punter in history.

The problem?  None of that notoriety comes from his actions on the field.  The Star Tribune’s Chip Scoggins danced around the elephant in the stadium when he wrote Kluwe’s Vikings career post-mortem in advance:

Kluwe’s departure will make the Vikings locker room a lot more dull because he is incredibly intelligent, articulate and passionate about societal issues. He’s a fascinating individual in a sport that breeds conformity. The NFL has become so big and so powerful that players often cling to political correctness for fear that a ripple might swell into a tidal wave. Kluwe is that surfer dude on top of the wave, hanging 10 on any issue that stirs his emotion.

“No single thing that I do defines me as a person,” he said. “Just because I play football, that doesn’t define me as a person.”

Chris Kluwe: like so very focused on his job

The message is unmistakable – Chris Kluwe’s gay marriage advocacy cost him his job.  And Scoggins et al are correct…sort of.

Kluwe’s value to the Minnesota Vikings was as a $1.4 million a year player at a reasonably expendable position.  Simply put – you don’t get to be a distraction if you’re easily replaceable.  And by every definition, Chris Kluwe is a distraction.  Kluwe has run his mouth on issues beyond gay marriage.  He’s been fined for “campaigning” for Ray Guy to get into the Hall of Fame.  He’s appeared on the website Deadspin several times over the 2011 NFL Lockout where he attacked numerous players over their views.

Chris Kluwe: so super duper focused on his job

Worse, Kluwe’s tactics are the epitome of his generation – foul-mouthed personal attacks against anyone who disagrees.  Pro-lockout players are “douchebags” who stand for “pretty much the definition of greed.”  His opponents are “a**hole f**kwits”, which also suggests he’s a plagiarist since I’m sure he stole that from Oscar Wilde.

In truth, the media needs Chris Kluwe’s release to be about his vocal and abusive activism.  Because admitting to solidarity with Kluwe’s political views, and his ability to deliver good copy to sportswriters and sports radio networks, is harder than portraying the SoCal punter as a victim of a 1st Amendment NFL crackdown.  Does anyone seriously believe that if Kluwe had come out passionately against gay marriage (ala Matt Birk), and saw his production dive, that those arguing against Kluwe’s release today would be defending his penchant to “hanging 10 on any issue that stirs his emotion”?

Chris Kluwe: so focused…on finding his next job

Kluwe mocked even his own Special Teams coach for suggesting the punter needed to focus on his job with the hashtag “so focused.”  Here’s hoping that Chris Kluwe finds the time to focus on realizing that being a public relations bully to those who don’t share his worldview isn’t the best way to advance what’s left of his career.

9 thoughts on “Without a Kluwe

  1. Kluwe’s incoherent papspew makes professional antagonists look like arrogant, witless douchbags. I am highly offended.

  2. I’ve got to wonder if Kluwe is truly incredibly intelligent, or whether he’s simply just incredibly obnoxious and uninhibited. It seems that more and more, our “elites” aren’t exactly impressing the world with Solomonic wisdom.

  3. The NFL loves guys who outperform their contract (at least until it’s time to negotiate) and are “intolerant” of guys who underperform it, or appear likely to underperform. This is especially true since there are no guaranteed contracts, and provisions that mitigate “dead money” relatively quickly compared to MLB and NBA. If you can provide “value” then they really don’t care too much about your “values”, even if they are exemplary. (Let’s not forget the Vikes also released Antoine Winfield this off-season).

    Kluwe was mediocre to average the last couple of years; it doesn’t bode well if your best ever net punting average still has you in the middle of the pack (and you also happen to make over a million dollars). Further, the Vikings were doing Kluwe a favor by releasing him this early (something he had also requested), allowing him more time to find another job. I suspect, however, that the market won’t be hot and heavy for him. My guess is he’ll be brought in late in pre-season or early in the year as an injury replacement for some team with issues at the position. His outspokenness will work against him some, but only if it’s a “tie-breaker” when a team is considering him and another reasonably adequate kicker.

  4. The Vikings are selling entertainment. Having one of your employees actively, very publicly, and repeatedly offend 50% of your potential audience (and likely more than that of your “core” audience since I doubt that Avery Liberelle spends Sundays glued to the tube) isn’t a good thing.

  5. Why do all these endorsements and “out-comings” appear so late in the game. President Obama’s pre-election evolution has been the only transparency of his administration.

    Kluwe’s stance seems to have become well known (because a non-sportsperson like me knows about it) only when his contract was in jeopardy. The recently self-outed basketball player (I forgot his name) also appears to have been waiting to do so until his declining years. Much to the surprise of (and total disregard for) his fiance of eight years. While I’m sure she had her own reservations about becoming engaged to a professional basketball player, I bet she didn’t see this coming …

    Is my opinion that all this stuff has been more about self gain or preservation than it is for any allegedly “noble” cause?

  6. Pingback: # Still So Focused | Shot in the Dark

  7. Pingback: Footloose | Shot in the Dark

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.