Mental Footnote
Monday, May 12th, 2025I’ve said it quite a few times; I support capital punishment for every reason but one – the inevitability that the state will execute the wrong person. And given that that is one of the ultimate wrongs – an innocent person dies, the guilty party goes forever free – that’s all the reason I need to oppose capital punishment.
And it’s not just an intellectual parlor game; we’re fairly certain one innocent guy was executed; there are suspicions about many other such cases. And the fact that well over 100 people have been freed from death row because their convictions were overturned, in most cases because they could not have committed the crimes for which they were convicted and sentenced to death, usually after sitting on death row for many years, as some conservatives demand the curtailing of appeals, which would have led to several more executions of the innocent?
Color me unconvinced. Or, rather, utterly convinced.
So, with all that said: a “botched” firing squad execution in South Carolina left a convicted murderer not quite dead, for a while anyway:
There wasn’t much chance Mahdi didn’t commit his crime. Or, rather, crimes; he was convicted of three murders – the stabbing of Greg Jones in a drug deal gone bad, then shooting a convenience store clerk Christopher Jason Boggs in the face and finally shooting police officer James Myers 9 times. 3 to his head.
Any of which, but especially that last, might explain why three expert riflemen firing at fifteen feet missed a three inch target – a grouping I get with a handgun without a whole lot of ceremony at that range – leaving Mahdi in “excruciating pain” for about a minute.
I imagine there’s going to be an Eighth Amendment civil rights suit against the marksmen – if anyone has standing to take it to court.





