The Racket Swings Into Action

Good old Saint Paul.

The business economy just continues to spiral down the vortex; it’s schools are a disaster for African-Americans and other minority students; it’s choking on traffic, and obsessed with choking it further.

But apparently none of that is so serious that the city, in its infinite wisdom, isn’t going to try to socialize… Garbage collection.

And the city, having learned so much for watching the Met Council jam down the Green Line, is going about getting its way the way it always does; anyway it has to to get what it wants.

A reader from Merriam park emails:

Gotta love this report– they received survey responses from 2,000 residents and conclude that based on those responses, “a majority of St Paul want organized trash collection.” They’ve also concluded that immigrants and minorities have too much trouble making decisions to make a good decision in choosing a trash hauler, so this is better for them. Of course, it doesn’t appear that they asked too many in the poorer neighborhoods of St Paul, since their map (see .pdf through link below) indicates that more than 800 responses came from Mac Groveland/ Summit Hill zip code.

The reports are at the link above.

But here’s the map of the survey responses:

screenshot-macgrove.org 2015-10-15 09-27-48

So the “survey” drew 2,000 responses – and if we take each of the different “color” bands at their half-way point, it’s fair to estimate that 70-80% of them came from the city’s four most alpaca-wearing, Subaru-driving, NPR-listening, Jon Stewart-worshipping, Saint Olaf-alumni-ing, upper-middle-class, white, government-union-or-academia-employed, “Progressive” zip codes.

Seems pretty even-handed to me.

6 thoughts on “The Racket Swings Into Action

  1. I responded to that survey: no need to centralize it other than to create opportunities for graft for the city to grant contracts.

  2. I’m in Minneapolis. We have city trash pickup.

    Prior to that I lived in Edina, which had private pickup.

    In Edina we had twice-weekly trash pickup and weekly recycling.

    In Minneapolis, we have weekly trash pickup and biweekly recycling.

    Service was better in Edina, and they left far less spilled on the ground. Minneapolis, though is much more proactive about sticking notes on my garbage cans about the things they think I’m doing wrong.

    And Minneapolis charges more.

  3. The city of Fridley said it wanted to be more “friendly” to city streets, as an excuse to centralize control of trash. I said I liked the trash freedom we have currently, having already experienced trash totalitarianism in Minneapolis.

  4. Having grown up in Highland Park, I can, with authority, state that surveying MacGroveland and Summit Hill is “Surveying to their Base” for the City Council.
    My wife describes it as “Surveying those that read English well and have an interest responding to City Government.”

  5. Instead of a fence at the border, how about a fence around 55104 and 55105? Seems to me THEY ought to be the ones seceding.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.