Handicapping The House
By Mitch Berg
While the “Left MN” blog seems to be a re-boot of the late, demented but unlamented “Cucking Stool”, the site’s associate blogger Tony Petrangelo is one of those rare Minnesota leftybloggers who ought not be under police surveillance – a compliment I give rarely (becaiuse it’s rarely deserved). Over the years, he’s written some excellent stuff about polling, redistricting, and the mechanics of politics.
And this past week, he’s been releasing a set of predictions for the MN House and Senate. He’s done this before, by the way:
This is my second time doing race ratings of Minnesota legislative elections, the first time being in 2010. Here are links to my Senate ratings and House ratings from that cycle. I used a Safe/Tilt/Toss-up ratings scale and prior to the election I rated the Senate seats as 31 total DFL seats (Safe+Tilt), 19 total GOP seats and 17 Toss-ups.
The GOP won all 19 seats I had them winning. They also won every single race I had listed as a toss-up. They also won a race I had listed as Tilt DFL, the Don Betzold – Pam Wolf race. Clearly 2010 was a wave year for the GOP.
Still, as Petrangelo notes, it was a game effort:
That said, I don’t think my ratings did particularly bad especially since there was no sort of adjustment incorporated to account for the broader political context of the election.
We’ll come back to that.
As with my previous foray into race ratings I’ve kept this years version to an entirely numbers based exercise. Meaning at no point is a race rating the way it is because I made a subjective judgement about the quality of a candidate.
There’s some more methodology talk in there, which you should oughtta read, because it’s useful stuff and I don’t disagree with any of it.
Which is notable, in that my own ratings below are largely the opposite.
Well, not entirely; in many, maybe most cases, I agree with Petrangelo. In many others, I made a different prediction because of some qualitative aspect to the race that isn’t readily apparent in the empirical numbers Petrangelo used. A race held after a redistricting is going to toss a lot of those empirical measures up in the air – as will a wave election (as Petrangelo discovered in 2010). While this may not be a wave year, there’s a dynamic at work that I think will affect a lot of these races.
I’ll do the House of Representatives first. I’ll include the House District, the DFLer, the GOPer, Petrangelo’s rating, and mine; if mine differ from Petrangelo’s they’ll be in bold.
| HD | DFL Candidate | GOP Candidate | Petrangelo | Berg |
| 01A | Bruce Patterson | Dan Fabian | Lean GOP | I’m thinking Fabian’s pretty safe. I’ll call it Likely GOP |
| 01B | Marc DeMers | Debra Kiel | Toss-up | Incumbency, Obama’s weak coat-tails and a strong Byberg bid makes this Leans GOP in my book |
| 02A | Roger Erickson | David Hancock | Toss-up | I’m going to say Hancock holds this one. Leans GOP. |
| 02B | Brita Sailer | Steve Green | Toss-up | Toss-up. I’d say Sailer’s incumbency would count, but I don’t think the DFL’s that strong in the area. |
| 03A | David Dill | Jim Tuomala | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 03B | Mary Murphy | Keith MacDonald | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 04A | Ben Lien | Travis Reimche | Likely DFL | Likely DFL |
| 04B | Paul Marquart | Paul Sandman | Lean DFL | Lean DFL |
| 05A | John Persell | Larry Howes | Toss-up | I’m going to stay on “toss-up” for this one. |
| 05B | Tom Anzelc | Carolyn McElfatrick | Toss-up | Call me pollyanna, but I’m going with Lean GOP. Just a hunch. |
| 06A | Carly Melin | Roger Weber | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 06B | Jason Metsa | Jesse Colangelo | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 07A | Thomas Huntley | Therese Bower | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 07B | Erik Simonson | Travis Silvers | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 08A | Chet Nettestad | Bud Nornes | Safe GOP | Safe DFL |
| 08B | Bob Cunniff | Mary Franson | Likely GOP | Likely GOP |
| 09A | Don Niles | Mark Anderson | Likely GOP | Likely GOP |
| 09B | Adrian Welle | Ron Kresha | Safe GOP | Safe GOP |
| 10A | John Ward | Chris Kellett | Toss-up | Tough one. I’d like to make this “Leans GOP”, but Kellett’s a newcomer. |
| 10B | Joe Radinovich | Dale Lueck | Toss-up | Toss-up |
| 11A | Mike Sundin | Jim Putnam | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 11B | Tim Faust | Ben Wiener | Toss-up | Toss-up |
| 12A | Jay McNamar | Scott Dutcher | Toss-up | Toss-up |
| 12B | Rick Rosenfield | Paul Anderson | Safe GOP | Safe GOP |
| 13A | Richard Bohannon | Jeff Howe | Likely GOP | Likely GOP |
| 13B | Shannon Schroeder | Tim O’Driscoll | Safe GOP | Safe GOP |
| 14A | Anne Nolan | Steve Gottwalt | Lean GOP | Lean GOP |
| 14B | Zachary Dorholt | King Banaian | Toss-up | I’m going with Lean GOP. Redistricting, incumbency, the SCTrib endorsement and a great record will make this an easier race than 2010. Hopefully. |
| 15A | Joe Walsh | Sondra Erickson | Likely GOP | Likely GOP |
| 15B | Brian Johnson | Jim Newberger | Safe GOP | Safe GOP |
| 16A | Al Kruse | Chris Swedzinski | Lean GOP | Lean GOP |
| 16B | James Kanne | Paul Torkelson | Likely GOP | Likely GOP |
| 17A | Andrew Falk | Tim Miller | Toss-up | Toss-up |
| 17B | Mary Sawatzky | Bruce Vogel | Lean GOP | Lean GOP |
| 18A | Nancy Larson | Dean Urdahl | Likely GOP | Likely GOP |
| 18B | Logan Campa | Glenn Gruenhagen | Safe GOP | Safe GOP |
| 19A | Terry Morrow | Safe DFL | Safe DFL | |
| 19B | Kathy Brynaert | Thad Shunkwiler | Likely DFL | Likely DFL |
| 20A | Ryan Wolf | Kelby Woodard | Safe GOP | Safe GOP |
| 20B | David Bly | Brian Wermerskirchen | Likely DFL | Likely DFL |
| 21A | John Bacon | Tim Kelly | Lean GOP | Lean GOP |
| 21B | Bruce Montplaisir | Steve Drazkowski | Likely GOP | I’ll go with Safe GOP |
| 22A | Eugene Short | Joe Schomacker | Likely GOP | Likely GOP |
| 22B | Cheryl Avenel-Navara | Rod Hamilton | Lean GOP | # |
| 23A | Kevin Labenz | Bob Gunther | Likely GOP | Likely GOP |
| 23B | Tony Cornish | Safe GOP | Safe GOP | |
| 24A | Craig Brenden | John Petersburg | Lean GOP | Lean GOP |
| 24B | Patti Fritz | Dan Kaiser | Toss-up | Toss-up |
| 25A | John Vossen | Duane Quam | Lean GOP | I’ll call this Likely GOP |
| 25B | Kim Norton | Melissa Valeriano | Lean DFL | Lean DFL |
| 26A | Tina Liebling | Breanna Bly | Likely DFL | Likely DFL |
| 26B | Patrick Stallman | Mike Benson | Likely GOP | Likely GOP |
| 27A | Shannon Savick | Rich Murray | Lean DFL | Lean DFL |
| 27B | Jeanne Poppe | Nathan Neitzell | Likely DFL | Likely DFL |
| 28A | Gene Pelowski | Adam Pace | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 28B | Ken Tschumper | Greg Davids | Lean GOP | Lean GOP |
| 29A | Susann Dye | Joe McDonald | Safe GOP | Safe GOP |
| 29B | Barrett Chrissis | Marion O’Neill | Likely GOP | Likely GOP |
| 30A | Holly Neuman | Nick Zerwas | Safe GOP | Safe GOP |
| 30B | Sharon Shimek | David Fitzsimmons | Safe GOP | Safe GOP |
| 31A | Ryan Fiereck | Kurt Daudt | Safe GOP | Safe GOP |
| 31B | Louise Woodberry | Tom Hackbarth | Safe GOP | Safe GOP |
| 32A | Paul Gammel | Brian Johnson | Likely GOP | Likely GOP |
| 32B | Rick Olseen | Bob Barrett | Likely GOP | Likely GOP |
| 33A | Todd Mikkelson | Jerry Hertaus | Safe GOP | Safe GOP |
| 33B | Denise Bader | Cindy Pugh | Likely GOP | Safe GOP |
| 34A | Adam Fisher | Joyce Peppin | Safe GOP | Safe GOP |
| 34B | David Hoden | Kurt Zellers | Safe GOP | Safe GOP |
| 35A | Andy Hillebregt | Jim Abeler | Safe GOP | Safe GOP |
| 35B | Sam Scott | Peggy Scott | Safe GOP | Safe GOP |
| 36A | Grace Baltich | Mark Uglem | Lean GOP | Lean GOP |
| 36B | Melissa Hortman | Andrew Reinhardt | Lean DFL | Lean DFL |
| 37A | Jerry Newton | Mandy Benz | Toss-up | Toss-up |
| 37B | Jon Chlebeck | Tim Sanders | Lean GOP | Lean GOP |
| 38A | Patrick Davern | Linda Runbeck | Safe GOP | Safe GOP |
| 38B | Greg Pariseau | Matt Dean | Likely GOP | I’ll go with Safe GOP |
| 39A | John Bruno | Bob Dettmer | Likely GOP | ‘ll call this Safe GOP |
| 39B | Tom Degree | Kathy Lohmer | Toss-up | Given Obama’s non-coattails and an excellent campaign, I’ll run with Lean GOP on this one. |
| 40A | Michael Nelson | Safe DFL | Safe DFL | |
| 40B | Debra Hilstrom | Richard Cushing | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 41A | Connie Bernardy | Dale Helm | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 41B | Carolyn Laine | Laura Palmer | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 42A | Barb Yarusso | Russ Bertsch | Toss-up | I’ll call this one Lean GOP |
| 42B | Jason Isaacson | Ken Rubenzer | Likely DFL | Likely DFL |
| 43A | Peter Fischer | Stacey Stout | Lean DFL | This is a Toss-Up |
| 43B | Leon Lillie | Kevin Klein | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 44A | Audrey Britton | Sarah Anderson | Toss-up | Toss-up (UPDATE: Not sure how this one escaped me. Sarah Anderson is dynamite, and I’d actually change this one to Safe GOP, except that the western subs are weird and I don’t always understand them. Let’s be conservative and call it “Leans GOP“) |
| 44B | John Benson | Mark Stefan | Likely DFL | Likely DFL |
| 45A | Lyndon Carlson | Jeff Pauley | Lean DFL | Lean DFL, sorry to say. |
| 45B | Mike Freiberg | Reid Johnson | Safe DFL | Likely DFL |
| Liely DF46A | Ryan Winkler | John Swanson | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 46B | Steve Simon | David Arvidson | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 47A | Keith Pickering | Ernie Leidiger | Safe GOP | Safe GOP |
| 47B | Joe Hoppe | Safe GOP | Safe GOP | |
| 48A | Yvonne Selcer | Kirk Stensrud | Toss-up | Toss-up |
| 48B | Tori Hill | Jenifer Loon | Likely GOP | Likely GOP |
| 49A | Ron Erhardt | Bill Glahn | Toss-up | Lean GOP; Erhard’s the wrong guy in the wrong place at the wrong time. |
| 49B | Paul Rosenthal | Terry Jacobson | Toss-up | Lean GOP |
| 50A | Linda Slocum | Craig Marston | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 50B | Ann Lenczewski | Richard Bohnen | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 51A | Sandra Masin | Diane Anderson | Toss-up | Toss-up |
| 51B | Laurie Halverson | Doug Wardlow | Toss-up | Toss-up |
| 52A | Rick Hansen | Joe Blum | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 52B | Joe Atkins | Paul Tuschy | Likely DFL | I’ll call this Lean DFL |
| 53A | JoAnn Ward | Pam Cunningham | Lean DFL | This is a Toss-up |
| 53B | Ann Marie Metzger | Andrea Kieffer | Lean GOP | I’m calling this one Likely GOP |
| 54A | Dan Schoen | Derrick Lehrke | Likely DFL | Likely DFL |
| 54B | Joanna Bayers | Denny McNamara | Lean GOP | Lean GOP |
| 55A | Chuck Berg | Michael Beard | Lean GOP | Lean GOP |
| 55B | Travis Burton | Tony Albright | Safe GOP | Safe GOP |
| 56A | Dave Jensen | Pam Myhra | Likely GOP | Likely GOP |
| 56B | Will Morgan | Roz Peterson | Toss-up | Toss-up |
| 57A | Roberta Gibbons | Tara Mack | Toss-up | Lean GOP |
| Lean 57B | Jeff Wilfart | Anna Wills | Toss-up | Toss-up |
| 58A | Colin Lee | Mary Liz Holberg | Likely GOP | Safe GOP |
| 58B | Jim Arlt | Pat Garofalo | Likely GOP | Safe GOP |
| S59A | Joe Mullery | Cindy Lilly | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 59B | Raymond Dehn | Gary Mazzotta | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 60A | Diane Loeffler | Brent Millsop | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 60B | Phyllis Kahn | Kody Zalewski | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 61A | Frank Hornstein | Devin Gawnemark | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 61B | Paul Thissen | Nate Atkins | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 62A | Karen Clark | Kurtis Hanna | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 62B | Susan Allen | Tom Johnson | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 63A | Jim Davnie | Kirk Brink | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 63B | Jean Wagenius | Matt Ashley | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 64A | Erin Murphy | Andrew Ojeda | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 64B | Michael Paymar | Brandon Carmack | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 65A | Rena Moran | Daniel Lipp | Safe DFL | Safe DFL, more’s the pity |
| 65B | Carlos Mariani | Carlos Conway | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 66A | Alice Hausman | Mark Fotsch | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 66B | John Lesch | Ben Blomgren | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 67A | Tim Mahoney | Cathy Hennelly | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
| 67B | Sheldon Johnson | John Quinn | Safe DFL | Safe DFL |
Senate tomorrow!





October 24th, 2012 at 7:51 am
I think you’re right on Russ Bertsch’s race in 42A — he almost won last time in the old 50B and the new district is friendlier territory. Russ an excellent candidate and a really good guy, too. Dale Helm in 41A has a shot, I think. In my district (41B) the GOP candidate (Laura Palmer) is going to end up losing badly because of the 3rd party candidate in the race, Tim Utz, who ran as a Republican last time in the old 50A and became disenchanted with the party afterwards. It’s too bad, because Palmer deserves better.
October 24th, 2012 at 8:03 am
Mitch it would have been nice if you wrote one sentence in the article the predicted outcome just to have some idea what it was. I tried to do a rough count and got roughly 54 seats lean or safe DFL, 56 seats lean or safe GOP, and 22 toss ups (I lost track of two seats on count sheet so lets say 24)
Could be a long night.
Correct me if I’m wrong the eight congressional district (which includes the iron range) is like districts 1-7. The fact that I’m seeing any Repubican there is a sign long term for us to keep control of the house since those were seats the DFL used to add up with their Minneapolis and Saint Paul seats.
Walter Hanson
Minneapolis, MN
October 24th, 2012 at 9:28 am
D: I’m feeling good about a lot of races in CD4.
Walter: The prediction is coming up on Friday.
October 25th, 2012 at 1:09 pm
FYI, the predictions for 57A and 57B are FAR too conservative. The DFL candidate Wilfarht for 57B isn’t even actively contesting the seat, he’s been on a state-wide gay marriage tour. When he can be bothered with 57B, his default response is “well I was asked to run”. This is AT LEAST lean GOP.
And as far as 57A, that’s a pretty solid GOP district. The DFL opponents fundraising has been anemic, she has no lawns signs up, and near as we can tell has done no door knocking. There has been no literature mailed by her or on her behalf. You know, all the stuff you do if you want to win….especially as a challenger. This is solid GOP.
October 25th, 2012 at 5:16 pm
Is there a reason for thinking that Sarah Anderson’s race is a toss up? 44A seems like a fairly republican district that only got more red after redistricting (old number 43A). Also, Sarah seems likable.
October 26th, 2012 at 9:14 am
G,
No, there is not. As I noted, I ran with Petrangelo’s ratings unless I had a reason that jumped out at me not to. While I think Sarah is going to smother her opponent, for whatever reason I didn’t change my prediction in that race. See above (in a moment or two)