I Gazed Upon The Chimes Of Freedom Flashing
By Mitch Berg
Wisconsin throws off the shackles of unreasoning paternalistic oppression and becomes the latest “Shall Issue” state:
The GOP-controlled Assembly approved the bill on a bipartisan vote of 68-27.
The Senate backed the bill last week on a 25-8 vote, and the measure now goes to Walker, who supports it, for his signature.
Wisconsin would become the 49th state to legalize the carrying of concealed guns.
The legislation would require those who want to carry concealed firearms to obtain permits. It would allow people to carry concealed weapons in the state Capitol and other public buildings but not places like police stations and courthouses. Weapons also would be prohibited in buildings where posted notices bar them, and in places like Summerfest music festival at Milwaukee’s lakefront.
The closest thing to a downside, according to my fellow Green Room blogger “MadisonConservative”? Wisconsin conservatives had been hoping for “Constitutional Carry”, as in Alaska, Arizona and Vermont (and, starting July 1, Wyoming), which require no permit at all for the law-abiding citizen to carry, concealed or openly.
I’m OK with incrementalism – remember, Wisconsin has leapt from being one of two no issue states, straight over “discretionary issue” (which Minnesota was from 1974-2003, and again for a year or so in 2004-05) to the ranks of shall-issue states. Those states now number 39, leaving only nine states with “may-issue” laws, and only one, Illinois, which denies the human right of self-defense to its citizens (along with Hawaii and New Jersey, which have “may-issue” laws but rarely issue permits). Anything worth doing is worth taking the time to do right – and as more and more people see that the law-abiding gun owner is the least of this nation’s problems, I can see more states adopting unrestricted carry.
Which is not to say that there aren’t people who still just don’t get it:
But Matt Havighurst of Madison said he doesn’t like the bill “at all.”
Havighurst, 41, who was playing with his 3-year-old son, Noah, at the lakeshore at James Madison Park said if the measure passes the government should send out free signs saying “no guns allowed” to anyone who doesn’t want them on their premises.
“What are you going to do at a park?” he said of such signs. “Put them all over at every entrance?”
Perhaps Mr. Havinghurst should take his son to a park in Chicago – no carry permits and, for that matter, no legal civilian gun ownership – and test his theory.
But not with the kid. Too dangerous.





June 24th, 2011 at 10:23 am
Oh no, they will be washing the streets of Wisconsin with blood, due to all the shoot outs at the OK corral that will occur, just like it has in every other state that passed this crazy law!!!!!!
Well, maybe not, actually. That hasn’t happened anywhere.
June 24th, 2011 at 10:52 am
I’ll watch out for bullet fragments in my cheese and beer when this one passes. :^)
Any word on whether they’ll honor Minnesota permits?
June 24th, 2011 at 12:36 pm
Read the articles on this in the Madison and Milwaukee papers. Quite humorous as the anti-2nd amendment rights crowd used the EXACT same goofy arguments that they used here. About shootouts and the state fair and sporting events. Things like that.
June 24th, 2011 at 2:13 pm
Actually, I’d say that they got it right. The Constitutional Carry folks (aka Vermont carry) might have been happy with unlimited carry, but you couldn’t carry out of state since so many folks demand at least some license. These days it’s best to do the Utah course so you get maximum reciprocity.
@Chuck: the Madison and Milwaukee papers are right, there will be shootouts at the state fair and sporting events. Of course, there are such things now so I don’t think concealed carry will change THAT much since as we’ve seen it’s not the concealed carry folks who get involved in those in the first place. Law abiding folks tend to be law abiding folks, and the law abiding folks who go through background checks and take courses tend to be even more law abiding than the general populace.
June 26th, 2011 at 11:10 am
nerdbert, I’m pretty sure you can obtain a formal permit (if one desires) in the “Constitutional Carry” States. That allows for reciprocity with other States (MN recognizes AK).