Sincerest Form Of Flattery

Yesterday was the centenary of Reagan’s birth.

A sweep through Twitter and the leftblogs saw the usual wave of fact-challenged, context-denuded twaddle the left always rolls out when the topic turns to Reagan; deficits, tax hikes, the debt, the Soviet Union would have fallen anyway, Iran/Contra  (to which the answers are “the deficits paid for themselves, the hikes came to a small fraction of his cuts, hello Tip O’Neill, and nobody’s perfect”, respectively).

But just like during the glory days of the Cold War, when Sovietologists would pore over Soviet television broadcasts and reading Pravda and Izvestiya to find the subtle hints the regime would send via its official media, you can find a lot between the lines of the offical news organs of the American left as well.  In this case, National Public Radio.

Over the weekend, NPR ran a piece on Reagan’s 100th birthday.  The piece largely focused on…Barack Obama’s various mentions and tributes to Reagan, and the comparisons some (on the left) make between Obama and the greatest American president of any of our lifetimes.

Toby Harnden at the Telegraph notes the meme, by way of pointing out the cold water some of us are throwing on it:

Perhaps more surprising is that there is a new claimant to the Reagan throne this year: President Barack Obama. Having once routinely derided Reagan as, in the words of Democratic greybeard Clark Clifford, an “amiable dunce”, the liberal establishment is now seeking to embrace him.

Obama first tried to grab Reagan’s mantle three years ago when he cited the Gipper as a way of taking a shot at the Clintons by saying that the Republican had “changed the trajectory of America” in a way that Richard Nixon and Bill Clinton had not. Reagan, he added, responded to a feeling that “we want clarity, we want optimism, we want a return to that sense of dynamism and entrepreneurship”.

Harnden correctly points out what NPR wouldn’t; it’s just plain wrong:

Some Republicans fear that Reagan is facing a posthumous political emasculation by Democrats who play down his conservatism and recast him as a squishy conciliator.

There is little doubt that Reagan would have been dryly derisive of Obama’s policies and presidency. “Government is like a baby,” Reagan once quipped. “An alimentary canal with a big appetite at one end and no sense of responsibility at the other.”

Obama, by contrast, views government as a kindly nurse and the people as the baby. According to his mindset, the people should submit to those in government who know better and whose role is to make decisions and control the purse strings.

Comparisons between their speaking styles are both superficial (delivery is important – and still not the main point) and wrong (Reagan kept delivering great speeches from the beginning of his administration ’til the end; Obama’s fabled oratorical chops have seemed more rote and canned over time).

Just saying.

6 thoughts on “Sincerest Form Of Flattery

  1. Reagan had an undergrad degree in economics.
    Obama, on the other hand, is jaw-droppingly stupid on the subject.

  2. Pingback: Tweets that mention Shot in the Dark » Blog Archive » Sincerest Form Of Flattery -- Topsy.com

  3. Reagan not only had an undergraduate degree in economics, but he also had the mind to realize–as so many fellow Keynesian-trained economists did not–the weaknesses of the Keynesian model.

    The weaknesses which Dear Leader loves to implement, of course.

  4. Here’s the text of Obama’s speech to the US Chamber of Commerce earlier this month:
    http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/02/07/obama-chamber-of-commerce-speech_n_819571.html
    It’s as though Obama thinks that the way businesses create wealth and jobs is still to ship coal from WV and ore from the Mesabi Range to Pittsburgh, smelt steel, ship the steel to Detroit to make cars, and transport the cars by rail to dealerships across the US.

    An example:

    We also have a responsibility as a nation to provide our people and our businesses with the fastest, most reliable way to move goods and information. The costs to business from the outdated and inadequate infrastructure we currently have are enormous. That’s why I want to put more people to work rebuilding crumbling roads and bridges. And that’s why I’ve proposed connecting 80 percent of the country to high-speed rail, and making it possible for companies to put high-speed internet coverage in reach of virtually all Americans.

    Dear God. Obama thinks that US jobs are being outsourced to India and China because they have better infrastructure.

  5. I remember Ronald Reagan. I voted for Ronald Reagan. Barack Obama is not qualified to shine Ronald Reagan’s shoes.
    Yes, I said that.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.