Chanting Points Memo: The Cult Of Compromise
Wednesday, June 1st, 2011In anticipation of tonight’s game against the Detroit Tigers, who are ten games ahead of the Twins in the AL Central, Twins manager Ron Gardenhire gave a press conference early this morning.
“We’ve done our best to be bipartisan in the run-up to the game”, said Gardenhire, whose team has a .321 record so far this season. “The Tigers need to compromise!”
As the team tries to avert a sweep at Detroit’s “Filth and Crime Stadium”, Gardenhire noted “the Tigers’ manager is being boorish and intransigent; the people overwhelmingly support compromise in tonight’s game”, he said, citing a Star Tribune Minnesota poll showing fifty random Minneapolis adults support the Tigers forfeiting tonight’s game.
“We’ve reached out and given enough”, Gardenhire concluded. “It’s time for the Tigers to give a little”.
———-
Dayton’s case for “compromise” is about the same as Gardenhire’s. Let’s get clear on a couple of facts here:
- Dayton’s mandate is nonexistent: Dayton backed into office with 43% of the vote (DFLers will respond “But Horner favored raising taxes, too!” Perhaps, but you can not assume Horner’s voters supported him because of taxes; indeed, the DFL’s propaganda machine couldn’t stop reminding people what a “Republican” Horner was during the campaign; it’d be pretty funny for the DFL to try to have it both ways, but hardly unprecedented. It’s every bit as likely that 10% voted for Horner out of blind hatred of Mark Dayton as because taxes make them tingly), the second-lowest in history. He’s weak.
- The GOP ‘s mandate is real: The GOP majority in the Legislature, on the other hand, won big, with a broad mandate made even more lopsided by the fact that a disproportionate number of the DFL’s votes came from blowout races in the Metro. There was no mistaking it; it was the biggest turnaround in state political history, from the dismal 2008 race to crushing majorities in both chambers. The GOP is not only entitled to govern like they won – they’d be disingenuous not to.
The DFL’s only real support on this issue is astroturf, bogus polls, and endless browbeating.
Which is noisy and showy, but doesn’t mean a whole lot.





