It’s Fun Being Outside The Alamo For A Change
By Mitch Berg
The truism about conservatives throughout my cognitive life is that we just don’t do protests.We have day jobs and families, for the most part; standing around waving signs rarely rises to the level of “something we’re interested in”.
I remember throwing counterdemonstrations at antiwar rallies that drew 15 people against 3,000 neocoms. I did another to counterprotest a big pre-RNC warmup rally in Saint Paul in September of ’07 that drew maybe 50 people against 600 or so of the other guys. And while 15 against 3,000 is a fair fight, I was never interested in being fair.
But the Obama Administration changed all that. Last April 15, 600,000 workadaddy, hugammommy conservatives turned out to protest government spending. More still turned out at subsequent rallies – and, hardest to believe of all, thousands went to congressional Town Hall meetings to show powers that currently be that not everyone is enamored of the Hope and Change we’re being presented.
In other words, there’s been a huge change in the way conservatives see public activism.
But even that observation didn’t prepare me for what I saw today. I attended a protest outide an Al Franken pep rally for Obamacare in Minneapolis today.
I parked a few blocks up Central, and walked toward the Temple; seeing a crowd gathered at Central and Uni, I steeled myself to walk a gauntlet of “Public Option Now”-chanting, preprinted-placard-holding Obamacare supporters.
And I practically fainted when I saw the assembled crowd; close to thirty anti-Obamacare people, holding homemade signs. They were in a jovial mood.
There were perhaps three Obamacare supporters. One was a very articulate guy and fellow User Interaction designer – yes, we talked a little shop – who stated a coherent case with not a few protesters on his way in and out of the meeting.
Another – a tallish fellow who looked like an extra from “The Crazies”, scuttled about with a big sign that said “Yes, there are Death Panels; they’re called Insurance Companies”. I asked him “So that means Sarah Palin wasn’t lying or crazy?”, I asked him (this is basically the same thing I wrote last spring); His eyes wobbled a bit, and he scampered away. His idea of an argument seemed to be “you people are the minority!”. Over and over. And over. Again.
And there was one more. (Article about him to come shortly).
It was a pretty low-key time, until the rally let out. A few hundred Obama supporters, clutching pre-printed placard that they no doubt had spent the last hour waving on cue, milled out across the sidewalk. For the most part, they navigated the jovial, happy gauntlet of protesters without incident. (Again, one big exception coming shortly).
But a few of them? You could tell how bitterly they detested seeing dissent; their eyes burned with a thud-witted hatred that said, without speaking, “you were all supposed to go away after the election”.
I’d try to recap most of the arguments – but for the most part, they were ripped straight from the preceding pep rally, and made my eyes glaze over. People say conservative talk radio is dumb! (Actually, there’s another blog post in there, somewhere).
All in all, it was a lot of fun! Hope we can see you at the next one!
Nancy from Freedom Dogs was there, too.





February 21st, 2010 at 7:19 pm
[…] I noted in my previous post on the subject, there weren’t many pro-Obama counterprotesters. They were pretty standard-issue stuff; not […]
February 21st, 2010 at 7:19 pm
[…] var zflag_width="1"; var zflag_height="1"; var zflag_sz="15"; « It’s Fun Being Outside The Alamo For A Change […]
February 21st, 2010 at 10:10 pm
Dude, you gotta retire “workadaddy, hugamommy.” Seriously.
February 22nd, 2010 at 1:15 am
THe alternative is “meat and potatoes”, and I really need to write fewer food references, too.
February 22nd, 2010 at 10:16 am
You should update it to “workamommy, hugadaddy”.
It’s still better than the DFL’s version “workadaddy, hugadaddy”…..
February 22nd, 2010 at 1:46 pm
Dude, you gotta retire “workadaddy, hugamommy.” Seriously.
This from the vapid jester who uses the words “wingnut” and “teabagger” in 95% of his comments.
February 22nd, 2010 at 10:11 pm
Mitch, I’m the UX guy you talked to at the rally. I’m glad we were able to find some common ground on ways that the Senate bill will benefit small businesses like mine who are struggling with rising premiums.
I know we disagree on many aspects of the bill, but I’m guessing we’re both happy about some aspects of the compromise proposal the President released today — no public option, the Nelson deal is gone, no special exemptions for unions. (I’m also happy that the subsidies for the middle class have gotten more generous, which has been my major complaint with the Senate version.)
I just wanted to say that I enjoyed my discussions with the protestors on Sunday. I think I was able to clear up some misconceptions about the bills — for example, the gentleman we talked to who didn’t realize that a core component of the bills lets individuals and small businesses pool their resources to increase their purchasing power — and I may have convinced a few folks to at least take a second look at the more moderate Senate bill.
Anyway, I believe that only good things can come from discussing our views and concerns on this issue. Perhaps I’ll run into you again at a future rally.
February 23rd, 2010 at 8:53 am
HCRN,
Nice meeting you as well. Talking is better than yelling.
Except when baseball or rollerderby is involved, natch.