Matt Stoller: Unamerican

By Mitch Berg

No matter how they undercut the military, no matter what loathing they pour upon America’s system and elected adminsitration and capitalist system and history, no matter what horrors they’ve coddled as they do so, it’s established that one dare not call any liberal “unpatriotic”, for fear of being called an ugly angry conservative.

But apparently, if you’re a major-league leftyblogger, wanting to keep more of the money you earn not only makes you unpatriotic, but it means you hate democracy.

It’s not a coincidence that Grover Norquist, the architect of the right-wing ascension to power, runs an organization called Americans for Tax Reform.  People like Norquist, who are charlatans at heart and deeply unpatriotic and immoral, use the complexity in the tax code that they help to create to persuade Americans that taxes are bad.  This is also true in states all over the country, where it is the unpredictability of property tax burdens and not the amount that causes schools to go wanting for funding.

Our tax code is the DNA of our nation’s moral compass.  I am proud to pay taxes because I take pride in America, and paying some tiny burden to keep our society running is an extremely small price to pay for being able to call myself an American citizen.  The old expression ‘you get what you pay for’ is apt for all sorts of situations.  People tend to express what they value in how much they are willing to pay for it.  I am willing and feel privileged for the right to pay for my country.  The right-wing is embittered to do so, if they do so at all.  And that, more than anything, says something about how much they value this experiment called America

No, Matt Stoller; as Thomas Jefferson himself averred, keeping a lid on the size, power and appetite of government is fundamentally American and itself deeply patriotic; our founding fathers believed that government was not so much an enemy (let’s be realistic) as a animal that needed to be kept tame.

But much more important for this “experiment called America” is the ability and willingness to accept that dissent and difference aren’t themselves base and evil. 

Not to do so is a form of moral retardation that is itself deeply antithetical to what this country is about.

3 Responses to “Matt Stoller: Unamerican”

  1. nate Says:

    I wouldn’t mind paying as much as I do if I actually could see what I paid for.

    What am I getting for my money? It’s not street repair. That’s specially assessed. Sewers, same. Alley plowing, private. Water and sewer are billed.

    My neighbors and I pay enough in St. Paul property taxes to have our own personal cop. So where is he? I never see him. Which is a good thing, I guess; but then what am I paying for?

    New carpet in the mayor’s office? I should be happy about that?

    .

  2. Terry Says:

    Here you have lefty blogging at your finest. First call your political oppenents unpatriotic and immoral. Then mix up some metaphors and imply that without taxes we wouldn’t have a society.

    Our tax code is the DNA of our nation’s moral compass. I am proud to pay taxes because I take pride in America, and paying some tiny burden to keep our society running is an extremely small price to pay for being able to call myself an American citizen.

  3. Colleen Says:

    What kind of self-righeous pigs are these people?! Is this what socialism does to the brain? It makes my head want to explode. My husband and I were talking about this very thing yesterday…what do we see for the tax money we pay out?! We work til May or whenever paying for….what? Our kids are long out of school and if they weren’t, they’d be schooled “alternatively”, not in any government school-our son is in law enforcement so it’s nice he gets paid, I spose…but other than that…what?! So an illegal alien can pay $1 in tax and receive $3 in services from the government….and they’re criminals! I don’t think that’s “quite right”. How about the able-bodied welfare cases and women on their 6th kid with 5 different dads? No good comes of any of it. Immoral is spending money that you yourself have not earned.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

--> Site Meter -->