Duckspeak
By Mitch Berg
Katherine Kersten – the best general columnist in the Twin Cities – on the U of M’s continuing effort to expunge Christmas, Christ and Christianity from the U’s public consciousness:
December office parties of any kind are now suspect at our state’s flagship institution of higher education.
The problem, explain [U of M Human Resources orc Dee Ann] Bonebright and [Office of System Academic Administration bureaucrat Julie] Sweitzer in their memo, is that “celebrations held in December tend to make people think of Christmas, whatever the theme.” And who knows where that could lead?
Due to what they call “seasonal creep,” warn Bonebright and Sweitzer, “an event that is meant to be a seasonal celebration [with no allusion to Christmas] suddenly looks very Christmasy when decorated with green and red.”
And here I thought seasonal creep referred to that guy who can’t keep his hands to himself or his nose out of the punch bowl.
Anyway, don’t suppose that including acknowledgements of Hannukah and Kwanzaa can keep an event from looking too Christmasy. That sort of inclusiveness, say Bonebright and Sweitzer, can be seen as “insensitive” and “won’t change the underlying message.”
Like what? Peace on Earth, Good Will to Men?
The U’s burearcrats seem to think that people’s productivity will plummet if they are exposed to – try to keep this straight – people with different worldviews. People with different traditions, who celebrate different things. That Moslems, Hindi, or Atheists will be so paralyzed with ire at the notion of people celebrating a Christian (and, these days, secular as well) tradition that they’ll turn into sullen lumps.
Which makes one wonder how a Moslem, Hindu or Atheist manages to do anything at all, in our out of work, in a nation that’s at least nominally 85+% Christian.
Kersten:
But Christmas or holiday parties, or whatever you call them, have a very different purpose. They remind us that life is about more than spreadsheets — that there’s a world beyond the office where real human beings laugh, talk about their families, and share the interests that give their lives meaning, fun and joy.
If we forget this, we risk sucking everything warm and human out of this wonderful season of the year.
The only “warmth” that seems to matter to the U – and much of the rest of official Minnesota – is that tingly feeling you get when nothing, ever, offends anyone, no matter how hard one reaches for it.





December 23rd, 2007 at 10:21 am
“”Katherine Kersten – the best general columnist in the Twin Cities””
Satire, right?!? *laughing*
December 23rd, 2007 at 11:17 am
Well, Mitch, you and Kersten are wrong.
There’s nothing wrong with being exposed to other traditions. The problem is with the government institution being the host.
And no, “equal time” doesn’t work. Adding a made-up African-American holiday and a relatively unimportant Jewish one does nothing to promote real understanding. It just assuages the liberal guilt for having a Christmas party, which is still what it is.
But, hey, ask Joel for his one-sentence summary of Chanukah, as presented to an elementary school class. Priceless.
December 23rd, 2007 at 11:29 am
There’s nothing wrong with being exposed to other traditions. The problem is with the government institution being the host.
Perhaps, but you know darn well that Official Minnesota is discouraging the private expression as well.
December 23rd, 2007 at 12:09 pm
“There’s nothing wrong with being exposed to other traditions. The problem is with the government institution being the host.”
We have a problem if the U is going to follow all the rules of ‘a government institution’. There goes academic freedom, politics on campus, etc. A university is not a high school.
Sounds like HR & admin busybodies at ‘work’.
December 23rd, 2007 at 6:35 pm
In 8.5 years of work at a government job I have never been to a “holiday party” where the the institution was the host. *shrug*
December 23rd, 2007 at 7:22 pm
As always like to say….If Kawazana is eqvilent to Christmas, then Ann Coulter is the same as Martin Luther King.
December 23rd, 2007 at 7:25 pm
I know many people of many relgions (and non-religions) who all celebrate Christmas. So far the only people I met who don’t celebrate Christmas (and I mean personally met and talked about the subject) are anti-Christian bigots. We have some where I work who are big supporters of my employers ban on Christmas.