Open Letter To Ron Paul Supporters In The 4th CD

To: Ron Paul Supporters, especially in the 4th Congresisonal District
From: Mitch Berg
Re: Your Shot At Making A Real Difference


Some of you know me.  I’m Mitch Berg.  And long before I had a blog, and even longer before I hosted a talk show, and longer-still before I got heavily involved in “establishment” party politics, I was a Libertarian, with a big “L”:.  I even ran for office as a big-“L” Libertarian  – and won a moral, if not literal, victory.

I support liberty.  I also support being in a position to actually affect policy, rather than being an eternal protest-voter.  All of your chanting and zeal witthin the GOP are of no value – zero, nada, zilch – if you don’t have the ability to actually affect policy in the world outside the party.  And while having your guy win the presidency would do that, you also need to push candidates with your worldview into the US House and Senate, Governors and state constitutional offices, state Legislators and Senators, the county commission, city hall, the school board – the stuff you actually have to win if you want the government to, y’know, audit the Fed and stuff.

Which is why I endorsed Paul – Rand Paul, that is – last winter.  Libertarian purism, like any kind of purism, is a fun self-indulgence – and like any self-indulgence, it will have no affect on society around you.

So I have no beef with libertarianism.  I don’t even have so much a beef with Ron Paul, either.  I approve of many of the issues he runs on.  The stuff he wrote 30 years ago is a big problem – don’t kid yourself.  But I want to support him, or at least what he stands for.

The problem, I’m sorry to say, is many of you, his supporters.  Part of it is that so many of you do in fact propose using the power of the executive branch in a way not a lot different than liberals propose using the judicial branch – as a cudgel.

But the bigger part is that, for too many of you, Ron Paul is a personality cult.  I’ve run into too many Paul supporters who support Paul, but can barely articulate what he stands for; indeed, I do a better job of speaking for what Paul believes than they do.

Worse?  Just like four years ago, you flooded GOP precinct caucuses, and are in the process of flooding the BPOU Conventions, and trying to push your delegates on to the CD, State and (you hope) National conventions.  And that’s fine; that’s how the process works.

What’s “worse” is that, like four years ago, so very very very very very many of you will never be seen again after your next round of conventions.  You’ll show up, do your bit for Ron Paul – but not the GOP – and disappear, likely not to be seen again.  There are some exceptions – but they are rare.  Your commitment is to Ron Paul, not to the GOP, even in the context of “Changing the party into a more-libertarian institution in the long term” – with which I’d be completely on board.

And so those of us who have committed to the party – some of you call us “the establishment”, which makes me laugh, since I’ve been a libertarian insurgent in the party for 12 years now, and being “the establishment” means “campaign after campaign of door-knocking, phone-calling and lit-dropping – do feel a bit of resentment, like when you cook a big dinner and some stranger eats the whole thing and doesn’t even say thanks.

Anyway, I’m not here to bag on all you Ronulans.  I’m here, actually, to propose a win-win solution; you get to push liberty, the GOP gets to make inroads in the arena of actually changing policy in a meaningful way.

We have a big opportunity in the Fourth Congressional District.  I’ll take a moment to remind you what the Fourth CD is, since a disturbing number of you Paul supporters have little concept of politics down-ticket from the Presidency.  It’s Betty McCollum’s Congressional District:

It’s been controlled by big-government stooges from the DFL for over sixty years now.

But the latest round of redistricting made it a lot more competitive.  It used to be pretty much Saint Paul – a 70-30 statist-DFL district.  But redistricting added in a bunch of the more-conservative, more liberty-friendly East Metro, including thousands of people who moved to Lake Elmo, Woodbury, Stillwater and Afton to get away from the DFL and the rot they bring.

Now, Tony Hernandez is currently the candidate running for the GOP nomination in the 4th CD.  I’ve interviewed him a couple of times – and the language he uses is the kind of thing that should make you Paul supporters (and me) happy to support him.  Big on liberty, shrinking government – most of the Ron Paul elevator pitch is in there.   Before redistricting, he might have been looking at a 65-35 campaign, if he was lucky.

Now?  The odds are not nearly so quixotic.  With a little luck and a ton of work, it’s doable.

So here’s the deal, Paul supporters; if all of you turn out between now and the election with as much enthusiasm and whiz and vinegar in support of Tony Hernandez – who likely will get nominated, as opposed to Paul – and work your asses off alongside all us “establishment” Republicans?  We might just pull off a miracle.

No, bigger than that.

And not just a miracle in terms of sending Betty McCollum back to work as a receptionist at Alliance for a Better Minnesota; not just a miracle in upending sixty years of statist big-government representation in the 4th CD.

It’ll be a miracle in terms that matter much more, both to you Paul supporters and to the GOP; you’ll have done some real, palpable good in bringing your beliefs to bear in a way that can actually affect policy.

If you’re interested in helping out?  I’ll see you at the conventions.  We’ll have a great time. We’ve got a lot of work to do, and we’ll have fun doing it.

If you’re not? If you’re one of those dolts who believes that by staying home on election day because your candidate didn’t get nominated you actually “send a message” anyone will care about?  It’s not true, by the way – politics, especially at the grassroots level, reflects the will of those who show up.  Not just once, mind you, but every month, every election.  Anyway – yeah, I’ll be working against you.  Totally.

Whaddya say?

That is all.

13 thoughts on “Open Letter To Ron Paul Supporters In The 4th CD

  1. *sigh* Wish I could believe this will have any impact. But I remember telling Ron Paul supporters this four years ago.

    I recognized many of their faces at our BPOU Convention….barely, because the last time I saw them was four years ago.

    They show up, demand their delegate spot, insist there is a conspiracy to deprive them of it, and then disappear for four years. Rinse, repeat. And then apparently are shocked when I don’t pay them instant respect.

    I’m honestly don’t give a damn about the Ron Paulers. They don’t show up anyway, so who cares if those of us that do the work end up in alternate slots?

  2. Wish I could believe this will have any impact.

    “The likelihood that one might fail ought not dissuade a man from a noble cause”
    — Abraham Lincoln, speaking to the MN 4th CD convention, 1860.

  3. I’m attending my BPOU this Saturday as a delegate and heard from a friend who attended his in the 3CD that it ended up going until 9pm because of some of the parliamentary stupnanigans that was pulled that dragged out the process. Any advice from anyone who had similar experiences so we can avoid the same problems this Saturday (other than the obvious: under no circumstances agree to suspend the rules after they’ve been adopted).

  4. Having been heavily involved as well since 2008, I think you can say the same thing about all the different candidates delegates. I think that is the case for 95% of all the delegates. Think about it.

    In Wright County, people helping in parades, party events, and BPOU activities have been heavily tilted towards Ron Paul supporters lifting the load. Heck, there have been a few off year parades were ONLY Ron Paul supporters (as well as the candidates) even showed.

  5. I gave a mini speech on this at my SD 41/49 convention last saturday during my run for executive committee. I said to the Ronulans not to give up and take your ball and go home. They think just because they get elected to conventions it means they can steamroll over the other 70% of us. I butted heads with them too but sadly I don’t think I’ll ever see them again. Funny thing was back in 2004, as a 17 year old political novice I did virtually the same thing only I didn’t have a candidate I was supporting, just my conservative-libertarian ideals. I still have that edge to me but you have to compromise, its how politics work.

  6. We have our BPOU on Saturday for the new SD41, which is mostly the artist formerly known as SD50. I don’t expect too many Ronulans; most of the Paul supporters in the old SD50 were college kids from Bethel, which is now in SD42 with the rest of Arden Hills. We get St. Anthony and more of Fridley in our district now.

    It will be interesting to see how this plays out.

  7. I was saddened to learn that Pat Mazerol will not be seeking reelection in 41B, stating increased responsibilities with work and family. I have to believe that redistricting had something to do with it, too.

  8. bosshoss, nope, his district got more red, less of bloomington and more of edina. He is the lead Elder at Wooddale Church and were (its the church I go to) in the process of finding a new pastor plus I think he’s got a few new grandkids. Keep in mind, this guy spent all of his life in the private sector so I have to think more than anything it was, I am not made out for this crap than anything. Rosenthal is running for the seat again and Downey is going up against Erhardt who finally showed his true colors and went DFL. Keith should crush him but I fear unless we come up with a strong candidate (endorsing convention to be held at the end of next month since we had no time to prepare) 41B will go blue.

  9. Pingback: The Real Republicans | Shot in the Dark

  10. Pingback: That CD4 Hangover | Shot in the Dark

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.