Can you fog a mirror? Then you too can be a lieutenant governor!
As Yvonne Prettner Solon bids farewell to the office of Lieutenant Governor, should Minnesota do so as well?
When it comes to political shockwaves, the announcement that Lt. Gov. Yvonne Prettner Solon would not seek a second-term as Mark Dayton’s running-mate barely constitutes a ripple in the political waters. And why not? Over the past four years, Prettner Solon joined a long and undistinguished list of Minnesota lieutenant governors who served their time largely under the radar of the media and electorate. Even Prettner Solon’s own webpage touts her “actions” as a small collection of out-of-state/out-of-country travels, with a dash of in-state touring on behalf of federal initiatives (helpfully spelling as a typo as well).
Prettner Solon’s (in)actions say less about her tenure than about the limitations of the office of lieutenant governor itself.
John Nance Garner’s infamous quote about the Vice-Presidency as “not worth a bucket of warm piss” (often sanitized as “warm spit”) might as well apply to Minnesota’s lieutenant governors. With perhaps the exception of Lt. Gov. Carol Molnau, who served as the commission of Transportation in the Pawlenty administration, Minnesota’s lieutenant governors have served almost no active role in policy direction or political leadership.
Indeed, the trend-lines for the state’s lieutenant governors have seemingly further minimized an insignificant position. Whereas past lieutenant governors had gone on to serve in higher office, such as Rudy Perpich, Sandy Keith, Karl Rolvaag, C. Elmer Anderson and Edward Thye, the past several decades haven’t even seen lieutenant governors make a post-office political impact. Joanne Benson, Joanell Dyrstad, and Marlene Johnson all made bids for higher office in the 1990s (Governor, U.S. Senate and St. Paul Mayor, respectfully) and lost – badly. None of them even made to the general election.
All of this begs the question – does Minnesota require a Lieutenant Governor?
Seven states forgo the position, with two of those states, Tennessee and West Virginia, having the office of lieutenant governor be only an honorary title on the Speaker or President of the State Senate. The line of succession, often the only value to the office, goes either to the Senate President or the Secretary of State. In Minnesota, about the only other value to the office is as a gender counterweight to the top of the ticket. Lou Wangberg was the last male lieutenant governor of the state – a fact useful only as trivia for political nerds. Otherwise, every winning ticket (and most of the losing tickets) have had a female running-mate since 1982.
Closing the office of lieutenant governor won’t save Minnesota much. The combined office budgets of the Governor and his lieutenant are only $3.3 million. But if Minnesota could willingly end a constitutional office like State Treasurer, which had at least some active management in state affairs, then why not do the same for a office that has strayed far from any meaningful policy or political moorings? Every candidate for governor claims they will reinvent the office of lieutenant governor with their selection. Dayton himself promised that Prettner Solon would become a “strong partner” if elected. If travelling to Canada and opening a Duluth office were parts of Dayton’s idea of partnership, he didn’t say in 2010.
Outside of the endorsement process for both parties, the role of lieutenant governor serves absolutely no purpose. And in an era where it appears both parties are drifting away from placing much value on being the endorsed candidate for governor, whatever justifications remain for the office are quickly disappearing.
ADDENDUM: Even Prettner Solon seems to have expected more out of her office, if her comments at her press conference were accurate:
She has said she and the governor have a distant relationship. She said she anticipated being more involved in more policy initiatives as lieutenant governor, but she carved out a niche of her own working on initiatives for seniors and Minnesotans with disabilities.
Exactly, FR. Minnesota lieutenant governors might as well be in the federal Witness Protection Program. Actually, perhaps they are. Anonymity is much more assured for lieutenant governors than mob informants.
Your addendum. So in other words, she was a token woman on the ticket. Given a non job. Kind of an affirmative action hire.
I’m not sure what she may have expected. She was the third wife of long-term Duluth DFL legislator Sam Solon. She succeeded him after he died in office. She pretty much took his seat based on his reputation and support base. Good for her, but I don’t recall her having much to offer other than her legacy office. After all, she is no Mae Schunk …
Maybe it’s possible that she’s moving out of the way for a more viable candidate who could take over for Governor Dayton in the event of “an emergency”, or to succeed him whenever he chooses to step down.
Keep the post but actually have the person do something. One Governor can’t be everywhere, especially one with a bad hip. Have the Lieutenant attend committee meetings while the Legislature is in session, meet with “non-leadership” members to mine their ideas. The position could actually be quite useful to the Governor and the State.
Think about this a little more carefully. Do you really want Mark “Soros Project” Ritchie a heartbeat away from the Governorship?
Bubba, I was thinking along the same line as you, and it sends chills up my spine!
She would have gotten along better if she kept a Pez dispenser full of Xanax at the ready and cultivated a taste for Jim Beam…probably.
I suspect that Mrs. Solon was chosen, at least in part, to make Governor Dayton more palatable to the 218-ers and other outstate democrats. Obviously his party affiliation is his big plus, but people up there can get a little quirky with things “Twin Cities.”
In another post, Mr. D attached an article which was flattering to Donnie Ness, the mayor of Duluth. I wonder if he could be an ambassador to the lands north of Hinckley and south of Rochester while developing into a stand-alone candidate?