Shot in the Dark

The Stupidity of Crowds

Any dictator can get some soldiers and shoot their predecessor and get into power, and then spend his term waiting for the next goon with soldiers to repeat the process.

For a dictator to get elected, they need large mobs of uninformed but inchoately angry people to put them into office.

But the mobs are like the soldiers in the first example; the dictator has to keep looking over his shoulder in case the mob turns on him.

So the dictator keeps the mob occupied.  Hitler pointed them at the Jews; Kristallnacht sent mobs of young Nazis into the streets to harass Jews, destroy their businesses, and make their lives miserable.  91 died.  Stalin kept the mob busy denouncing each other.  Hugo Chavez and  Ayatollah Khomeini and Fidel Castro and Saddam Hussein all found boogeymen, internal and external, to keep the mob from turning their wrath on them.

Now, Barack Obama is not a dictator.  He’s a democratically elected president. In 2012, when he loses in an electoral landslide (provided the GOP can get its act together) he’ll hand power over.

But Obama – the least-vetted, most inexperienced president in American history – was elected by a huge popular groundswell, animated by fatigue with the sitting administration and actively disinformed by a media whose legs tingled at the thought of The One taking office.

That “groundswell” has to be kept occupied during the dismal business of actually trying to run a government.

Last weekend on Marty Owings’ Radio Free Nation I noted that the “protests” we see carrying people to the homes of AIG executives to “protest” the giving of perfectly-legal but shamefully tone-deaf bonuses had echoes of the sort of populist mob action that led us to Kristallnacht.  The show’s liberal commentator threw a fit, of course; since 91 executives haven’t died, there are no parallels whatsoever (only liberalsl get nuance.  Did you know that?)

But even Kristallnacht didn’t spring fully-formed from nowhere.  It was part of an endless wave of legalized violence against those the regime needs to demonize to keep the mob occupied (and we all know where that wave ended, don’t we?)

Waves of eliminationist violence – the Holocaust, Rwanda, Darfur, the Holodomor – all start small.  And they all start somewhere.

At any rate,  today “the rich” – bankers, insurance executives – are the scapegoat.  And it’s starting:

…in Scotland, an “anti-capitalist” group attacked the home of Sir Fred Goodwin, former CEO of the Royal Bank of Scotland, smashing several windows and vandalizing a car parked in the driveway. Goodwin had been demonized in the press and attacked by British politicians, much like AIG’s management.

The reactions of bystanders are rather appalling. A neighbor “said she was surprised that [Goodwin’s home] had not been attacked before.” Others seemed understanding of, if not sympathetic with, the vandals.

No, Obama’s not chartering this sort of violent lunacy. But he, and his compliant media, are setting up “the rich” – today it’s AIG execs – as scapegoats for an economic downturn that has plenty of parents.  Mobs love scapegoats.  Scapegoats are bright, shiny things to keep mobs occupied so they don’t get cranky and turn on their leaders out of boredom.

In the meantime, look for the media and their less-bright cousins to focus obsessively on “right-wing violence”, no matter how hard they have to imagine it.


Posted

in

by

Tags:

Comments

16 responses to “The Stupidity of Crowds”

  1. angryclown Avatar
    angryclown

    Still whining about the election. Reduced to far-fetched comparisons to the Hitler, Peron. Wingnuts running on empty. Let me know when you think you’ve got traction on any of this nonsense, eh?

  2. angryclown Avatar
    angryclown

    Mitch informed: “Mobs love scapegoats. Scapegoats are bright, shiny things to keep mobs occupied so they don’t get cranky and turn on their leaders out of boredom.”

    Dear Wingnuts:

    Hey, thanks for the news flash!

    Signed,

    Immigrants
    Gays
    Hollywood
    Welfare recipients

  3. Chaosfish Avatar
    Chaosfish

    Putting aside AC’s well known talent/ predilection to yank our chains, (collectively speaking) Does he have a point ?

    Where do we draw the line between ‘energizing the base ‘ and ‘inflaming the mob’?

    There are people on both sides of the political aisle who are (overly) concerned about open borders or gay marriage or demonizing the rich or protesting an unpopular war.

    When does that concern go from policy dissagreement to full on mob mentality ?

    And is it possible in todays 24 hour news cycle , attention span of a ferret world to disagree in a civil manner with ones political opponents and not cross the line into crass?

    Dunno, just asking

  4. nate Avatar
    nate

    As the Obama administration proceeds in inadvertently destroy America’s wealth, it’ll need more scapegoats.

    Last week, it was Rush Limbaugh. Employees of the federal government are running an Enemies List operation out of the White House, against a private citizen who makes a living as an entertainer.

    This week, it’s AIG executives. Employees of the federal government are running an Enemies List operation out of Congress, against private citizens who make their living as bankers.

    The scapegoating is a distraction from the fact that the O-ministration has no clue how to get the economy moving; in fact, its proposed cures are worse than the illness.

    Banks aren’t lending and people aren’t spending because they don’t know what the rules will be, don’t know what zig the Oministration will zag next, can’t plan for the future. So they sit tight and cut back.

    You wait – before the year is out, a prominent Democrat will denounce “hoarders” and will equate them with “economic terrorists” whose actions are so damaging to the American economy that they are Enemies of the State and therefore, the rest of us are justified in taking what they have to give to more deserving people. The mechanism of the confiscation might be a 97% tax rate, or forced sale of shares of preferred stock, or maybe indictments to keep them tied up in court forever (or until the lawyers own all their assets).

    Mark my words. Rush. Bankers. Hoarders. Wreckers. Kulaks. They’re all enemies of the state.

    .

  5. nate Avatar
    nate

    Chaosfish: you might just scan some historical reports to see who inflames mobs to violence, and who whips up their base. I think you’ll see the results break down along these lines, 79% of the time:

    Fired up Conservatives donate money.

    Fired up Liberals destroy property.

    margin of error 3 percentage points.
    .

  6. Mitch Berg Avatar
    Mitch Berg

    Ah, Clown:

    Immigrants – The illegal ones? Do law or do laws not matter?

    Gays – Hello? 1960 called. It wants its meme back.

    Hollywood – Oooh, poor widdle Hollywood, getting criticizes for being myopically, unreasonably and reliably in the bag for Democrats! Whatever will they do?

    Welfare recipients – Nope. The unthinking entitlement system. Big difference.

  7. angryclown Avatar
    angryclown

    Ooh, poor widdle Bank of Scotland CEO! Did somebody break a window on your Aston Martin?

    Consult an ophthalmologist. You have a serious speck/beam problem, Mitch.

  8. Dog Gone Avatar
    Dog Gone

    I was appalled that apparently a full bus load of people turned up at one AIG’s home.

    One. Not many – and the executives are listed publicly, on every annual and quarterly report; heck, you can find them online through your computer or your local library.

    And, un-Krystalnacht-like, they appear to have had a polite conversation with the AIG executive, and then, politely, to have left.

    The analogy to mobs doesn’t quite hold up….

    People are frustrated, yes. Mobs acting destructively? No.

    There have been some positive indicators in the past week or so. Housing sector has improved surprisingly. The market has been trending strongly upwards (a lousy predictor of anything, but still…).

    I happen to agree that while some people DO deserve bonuses, there seems to be a consensus that some Wall Street execs have been receiving excessive compensation.

    I think I can reflect on this with a somewhat greater degree of insight than the much-touted Joe-the-Plumber, having grown up with daily dinner discussions of the stock market, real estate, commercial banking, and the behind-the-scenes maneuverings that went on at the board level of several corporations where my father sat on the board of directors.

    Some of the things I have seen that were deceptive and manipulative first hand? Working in the executive offices of a major national insurance corporation where the ceo had made a number of bad decisions that resulted in job losses. Publicly made a big deal, covered by the media, about forgoeing bonuses, and a large portion of his huge salary.

    What didn’t get the publicity, was not even widely known inside the company, was when he then took his entire salary, and bonuses, including an ADDITIONAL stock bonus four months later. Illegal? No. Deceptive and manipulative and underhanded? You bet.

    There are plenty of individuals who deserve to make big bucks, including honest and talented execs.

    But there are still plenty of jerks who do NOT deserve those bonuses when their company is NOT making money, who connive to grab the money anyway. Those AIG contracts were BAD BAD BAD, and there is a perfectly legitimate basis for some anger and dissatisfaction. I am skeptical of the integrity of anyone who participated in those contracts as reported in the congressional hearings, and so should be the general public.

  9. Chuck Avatar
    Chuck

    Clownboy….Gays are oppressed? My fortune 100 employeer is so pro-Gay rights that they crank showtunes in the common areas.

  10. Master of None Avatar

    Immigrants
    Gays
    Hollywood
    Welfare recipients

    I must have missed the bus tours targeting any of these groups.

    I wish angryclown would transform into angrymime and restrict himself to waving his arms around inside an unseen box.

  11. Badda Avatar

    So AC doesn’t care about private property as long as the owner can afford to fix and/or replace damaged or stolen property.

    Hmmm. Sounds like something we could take advantage of against him.

  12. K-Rod Avatar
    K-Rod

    “Does he have a point ?”

    No, AssClown is wearing his dunce hat.

  13. Troy Avatar

    Dog Gone said:

    “Those AIG contracts were BAD BAD BAD, and there is a perfectly legitimate basis for some anger and dissatisfaction.”

    How were the contracts bad?

    Who should be angry and dissatisfied?

    “I am skeptical of the integrity of anyone who participated in those contracts as reported in the congressional hearings, and so should be the general public.”

    So who do you think were the those who “participated”?

  14. Bill C Avatar

    nate;

    And is it possible in todays 24 hour news cycle , attention span of a ferret world to disagree in a civil manner with ones political opponents and not cross the line into crass?

    I’ve done both. I’ve had perfectly reasonable, quiet, well-mannered, engaging and though provoking discussions with co-workers (!) who are diametrically opposed to myself, politically. I’ve also had screaming, ranting “stupid ass conservative hypocrite!”-“stupid ass liberal hypocrite” discussions on the internet. Being in person tends to calm one down.

    I will submit for your observation: AIG protests, WTF protests where Seattle was rocked with violence, PETA/ALF protests where labratories are destroyed or red paint thrown on fur coats, RNC convention 08, etc etc etc. Show me where the equivalent behavior is exhibited by crowds on the right.

    The scapegoating is a distraction from the fact that the O-ministration has no clue how to get the economy moving; in fact, its proposed cures are worse than the illness.

    I think you are giving them too much credit with “they have no clue financially”. On the contrary, I think they know EXACTLY what they are doing. They are systematically trying to dismantle our capitalistic somewhat free-market economy and replace it with a huge dose of socialism. Obama’s not stupid. Inexperienced in foreign policy and executive experience, maybe. But he has an agenda, a congress willing to help move things along, and a media willing to provide the necessary distractions.

  15. K-Rod Avatar
    K-Rod

    Imagine the stupidity of a crowd of AssClowns!!!

    http://www.smooth3d.com/xterra/assclown.jpg

  16. […] the previous two postings, I wrote about the dangers of facile populism and the “Evita” phenomenon (people valuing charisma over […]

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.