Shot in the Dark

Unsafe Space

Think it’s cold and snowy?

Sit back and pour a bourbon.  We’ve got a story for  you.

You know what it’s like when your football team has a 21 point lead at the beginning of the third quarter, but then your opponent scores three touchdowns in an amazing display of skill, luck and clutch playing?  And it’s the two minute warning, and the game is tied, and all that “we got this” brio that you had 13 game minutes earlier is replaced by the realization you’ve got a lot of work ahead of you?

72 years ago today, the Battle of the Bulge began.

It was among the coldest winters in recent European history…

Sherman tanks of the 7th Armored Division outside St. Vith, a key crossroads that the Germans seized at great cost to both sides.

…cold enough that, as Steven Ambrose noted in Citizen Soldiers, even the boys from the Dakotas and Montana had met their match.

Covered by atrocious weather that grounded US and British tactical air – which, along with the US artillery, which was fast, accurate, available in huge quantities, and had a tradition of blowing things up with style going back to the Civil War, was the thing the Germans feared most – the Germans attacked the thinly held American lines near the point where Belgium, Luxembourg and Germany’s borders meet, in the Ardennes Forest.  Here, German troops had broken through three times in the past 75 years – in 1870, 1914 and 1940.

Nobody expected lightning to strike four times.  And it showed; the Americans considered it a quiet sector, and garrisoned it thinly, with brand new troops like the 106th Infantry Division, which was just out of training and had no combat experience, as well as the 2nd Infantry Division, which was resting up after having been bled white in the fruitless bloodbath of the Hürtgenwald.

The battle launched legends (the 101st Airborne’s stand at Bastogne, immortalized long before Ambrose’s Band of Brothers brought the story to the HBO audience)…

A paratrooper of the 101st Airborne, armed with an anti-tank Bazooka, watches a road outside Bastogne Belgium.

…and stories that should have been legends (a single platoon of 19 men under Lieutenant Lyle Bouck held off an entire 2,000-man German airborne regiment for a crucial day at the Battle of Lanzerath Ridge, which impeded the German SS-Panzer spearhead, costing it a vital day that may well have allowed the US 2nd Armored Division to get moved into place to stop the advance, to the low-key (the troops of the 99th Infantry Battalion – Norwegian-speaking men from the Dakotas, Minnesota and the Upper Peninsula of Michigan) stopping the German advance cold at Elsenborn Ridge, near Stoumont:

The position held by the 99th Independent Infantry Battalion – Norwegian-speakers from the upper Midwest, originally recruited for a Green-Beret-style role in the invasion of Norway – during the Battle for Elsenborn Ridge.

The high command, thinking Germany was on the brink of surrender, had decided to send new replacement troops to the Pacific to get ready for the invasions of Okinawa and, soon, Japan – so the casualties of the first days of the Bulge caused a huge shortage of manpower.  This gap was filled by pressing units of cooks, mechanics, construction engineers and clerks into service as provisional infantry units and, finally, the induction of black soldiers – many of them truck drivers – into replacement units.  The Army’s superstition at the time was that integrating units would sap morale – so black replacements were sent in 40-man platoons to reinforce companies that had started out as 160 men, but had been whittled way down.  Ongoing casualties caused these platoons to get divided into squads of 10 integrated into platoons of 20-30, and as the attrition went on and men got down to the brass tacks of survival, black and white soldiers sharing foxholes.   The officers who presided over this went on to

Want the whole story?  There are a scad of good books on the subject.  They’re worth a read…

…especially when you realize that the US troops that escaped into the woods, re-formed and turned the tide were, on average, about 19 years old – and there was no safe space, anywhere.

 


Posted

in

by

Tags:

Comments

9 responses to “Unsafe Space”

  1. Prince of Darkness_666 Avatar
    Prince of Darkness_666

    Grandpa fought in it as a green recruit right out of basic. Shot in leg day 1, bandaged up headed back into battle. Few days later had a shot bounce off his belt buckle. 1-2 inches lower and I’m not here. Very sobering

  2. shakingmyhead Avatar
    shakingmyhead

    And, one of the best answers of all times – “Nuts” by acting commander of the 101st General MacAuliffe, when asked to surrender during the Battle of the Bulge, The Germans didn’t understand what he meant, so he elaborated. “Go to hell”.

  3. Chuck Avatar
    Chuck

    The Germans brought in an army of 410,000 soldiers undetected. I suppose in pre-satellite days, overcast weather, etc. But still, as far as I know there was no warning of the attack.

  4. Chuck Avatar
    Chuck

    Conventional wisdom always said that this extended the war by about 6 weeks. Military historians now say no, it actually shorten the war as Germany shot the rest of their wad all in one location on a failed offense. They would have been better off using all those tanks and men in defensive positions in western Germany.

  5. Mitch Berg Avatar
    Mitch Berg

    But still, as far as I know there was no warning of the attack

    Not that was taken seriously, anyway. I remember reading that 2nd Infantry reported sounds of vehicles to their front. The reports got discounted.

  6. bosshoss429 Avatar
    bosshoss429

    Hmmm. Discounting reports of possible enemy movements. Apparently, they were no more concerned about those noises than a radar officer in Hawaii, who received a report from one of his radar stations that they had a large group of planes on their display early on a Sunday morning was.

  7. bikebubba Avatar
    bikebubba

    My great uncle, a reporter, on the right when the skies cleared. Page 28. Perhaps it was POD’s granddad who told him he was an idiot for getting out of the trench when there were still German snipers in the area.

    https://books.google.com/books?id=KVMEAAAAMBAJ&printsec=frontcover#v=onepage&q&f=false

    Most beautiful thing most infantrymen had seen for a while….the USAAF, not my great uncle…but my great uncle had seen something else pretty cool about that time, a telegram announcing that my grandmother had had her first daughter. The poor private was terrified because he knew my uncle had been away from home for over a year.

    Got to talk with a pastor who fought as a 16 year old on the other side…he lost several fingers to the cold and, though he’d hoped to protect his sisters and mother from the Soviets, was awfully glad he got captured by the U.S. Army instead. He ended up as a pastor in Kiel. And I was a student for six weeks where Hitler had collected many tank columns–Mayen, Germany, which was about 95% destroyed by the USAAF. The woman who owned the house where I lived remembered the German soldiers carving wooden shoes for her and other children, which they also used for sledding.

  8. Night Writer Avatar

    There were warnings. The reply from up above was, “1939 called. They want their battle plan back.”

  9. bosshoss429 Avatar
    bosshoss429

    Re the cold weather during the Battle of the Bulge, my wife’s uncle, who grew up in Baudette, was there and I remember him saying that it was colder that winter there than he ever experienced in Baudette.

    Forgot his unit, but he was his platoon’s BAR guy.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.