The Key Dichotomy

If you've been hiding under a rock, you might not know that the Northern Alliance's Captain Ed, along with a variety of new-media figures, have backed Dan Rather into a corner.

Rather says the bloggers who broke the Forgerygate story are savvy "partisan political operatives" presumably affiliated with the Bush campaign and/or RNC, but Jonathen Klein says they are a bunch of guys sitting around the living room in their pajamas.

Rather says the documents in question are authentic, but some of CBS's supporters have speculated that the documents were forgeries planted by Karl Rove.

Which is it?