Craig Westover posts a response to a comment from a post about education.
It sums up not only every reason the DFL must be kept from office in Minnesota, but in fact is a fine example of why I left the Democrat party, over twenty years ago:
So I guess that yes, I do lack a certain faith in individuals not in making decisions for themselves but in making decisions for their children which have enduring consequences. I think public schooling is a good way for society to safeguard its young and against the improvidential decisonmaking by their parents, just as I lack the confidence in individuals making providential decisions about their old age.Westover adds, seemingly dumbfounded:
I won’t refute what is said here. It is a far more damning indictment of liberalism standing alone than any rebuttal would be.Some liberals cover that intrinsic elitism better than others. But it is in education like no other issue where it comes out. Posted by Mitch at August 15, 2006 06:03 AM | TrackBack
Semi on-topic, have you seen the trailer for "The Children of Men?" Has the sheen of compelling film-making (I'm a sucker for that orchestral "Gimme Shelter") but I have to laugh when the hero's oddysey is revealed (no risk of spoilers - it's all in the trailer): he must take his charge, the world's only pregnant woman, to the Human Project: "the greatest minds in the world, working for a new society."
I suspect that prospect is inteneded to cause our eyes to glaze over in wistful gratitude. Maybe he's actually taking her to a Renaissance Weekend to find her Baby Daddy?
Posted by: Brian Jones at August 15, 2006 07:44 AMThat film must be based on the PD James novel of the same name. Don't know about the movie, but the book was great. It never approaches the subject of abortion but it's message is intensley, profoundly, and convincingly anti-abortion. Neat trick for James to pull off.
Posted by: Terry at August 15, 2006 10:10 AMYeah, I've been meaning to check that out. I've only read one of her books: "Devices & Desires," which is stunning. I've not read any of her others.
Posted by: Brian Jones at August 15, 2006 10:37 AMWow, I don’t believe I’ve read Captain Fishsticks before that was a very damning critique of what seems to be the dominant paradigm in what passes for thought amongst the Left: you cannot be trusted to make your own choices to improve your or your family’s lot in life. Unless of course we’re talking about terminating a fetus, then it’s the pharmacist who should not be allowed to make decisions about whether or not he wishes to sell birth control devices and aborticides.
Something else struck me about the issue of local control of education. So much of the argument we hear from the opposition is that Minnesota has a terrific educational system and by extension it’s a great place to raise your families. It seems to me then, if we’re doing so well with education (and let’s just assume for the sake of argument that’s true), they why WOULDN’T we want to keep the federal government out of it as much as possible so that the decisions are made by the people at the local and State level – the one’s who supposedly have created our terrific educational system? Unless of course implicit in the argument about the superiority of Minnesota’s educational system is the assumption that it’s terrific DESPITE rather than BECAUSE of the “collective wisdom” of people living in Minnesota acting through our duly elected school board members/legislators.
Thanks for giving me another blog to put on my "must read" list.
Posted by: Thorley Winston at August 15, 2006 11:29 AMuolap rozjte osuxyhw jksp kmfiy vrkubm fstoeknp
Posted by: hdouzmx ypcfgqol at September 6, 2006 04:29 AMfikcqyoz pqzk uwcvirbq abutghrs ugedxv seyrzhcli xmea
Posted by: flhcmt cdajnsqrt at September 9, 2006 01:04 PM