shotbanner.jpeg

April 15, 2005

Ye Shall Know Thy Market by Its Villains

Pious Agnostic has an observation about the new Michael Crichton book, State Of Fear:

It's a pretty good adventure story, and the ending had enough punch to give me a little frission of horror, though there are some things in this book that had me laughing out loud (and not in the good way).

But while entertainment is certainly a good reason to read this book, Crighton has another purpose for writing it: the dispellation of myths and foolishness about Global Warming.

(*spoiler alert*)

The bad guys in this book are a radical environmental group...

Whoah.

I mean, Tom Clancy's done that (Rainbow Six), but everyone expects it of Clancy...

Posted by Mitch at April 15, 2005 07:37 AM | TrackBack
Comments

Crichton has long been a crusader against the pseudo-science of today's environmental movement. Lots of great past speeches at www.michaelcrichton.com.

Posted by: chriss at April 15, 2005 08:55 AM

I recently finished it as well. I mostly like it, though it seems to want to be a few too many things at once (mystery/suspense/scientific reference). It has something of the Heinlein problem* of long expository lumps (with footnotes, even), but still fun to read.

* I like Heinlein a lot, except for his last stuff, but he does (did) preach.

Posted by: Doug Sundseth at April 15, 2005 11:51 AM

Sorry guys, thought the attack on the wacko-environmentalists was great, but the story-line is basically a piece of crap.

Really, is there anyone out there who didn't know the actor was the cannibal victim as soon the we learned of the maneaters?

Crichton has written worse books, but there is far, far away from his best.

Posted by: Grey at April 15, 2005 11:56 AM

Grey,

Yeah, I figured that the actor guy was lunch the minute he started spouting that "nobody has ever been a cannible" line.

That's the part that really got me, though. The description is pretty awful...

Posted by: Pious Agnostic at April 15, 2005 12:54 PM

The thing I found most distracting (other than the footnotes) was the near-complete absence of a justification for the billionaire, the lawyer, the secretary, and the professor (what, no Gilligan?) being required to save the world. There are places where even a baby airstrike would have stopped the problem faster and more certainly.

Not that the problem is unique to this book. It's the same thing as a cop show where the protagonists drive like maniacs all the way across town to warn/save the soon-to-be victims. What, no cell phones, no patrol cars, never heard of a pay phone? Sometimes it's really hard to suspend that disbelief.

Posted by: Doug Sundseth at April 15, 2005 04:49 PM

"It's the same thing as a cop show where the protagonists drive like maniacs all the way across town to warn/save the soon-to-be victims. What, no cell phones, no patrol cars, never heard of a pay phone? Sometimes it's really hard to suspend that disbelief."

I hear ya! I find myself worrying about the poor writers. What are they going to do without the oft used device of waiting to trace a call now that call waiting is so prevalent?

Posted by: Sandy at April 18, 2005 05:54 PM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?
hi