Oliver Willis - a young blogger who has become less cogent and readable as his traffic and popularity on the left have grown, who is employed by George Soros, did something very dumb yesterday.
Emphasis added:
I think it's kind of funny that the wingnuts at sites like Powerline have discovered the subtle art of "nuance" (the same thing they've been slamming Kerry for since he doesn't use kindergarten sentences like Dear Leader).Powerline are "wingnuts?"
Granted, they may not be capable of logic like this:
But here's the thing. Dear Leader didn't say anything resembling "Senator Kerry's words would have us believe" (not that the sorry excuse for a President could get such a complex sentence out), but blatantly lied and blatantly claimed that Kerry said: "he would prefer the dictatorship of Saddam Hussein to the situation in Iraq today". Look. Black is black and white is white, and George W. Bush is a heck of a liar, and Goldstein's a hell of an idiot apologist. John Kerry never said that. He just didn't.So, we have a gratuitous dictator reference, eight unsupported assertions (saying "he just didn't!", three flaming ad-hominae and an out-of-context assertion intended to mislead...
An example. If Kerry said "George Bush admitted that he's the shittiest president since Nixon", that would be a lie, because Bush would never say that. Now, were Kerry to say "George Bush is the shittiest president since Dick Nixon" he would be telling the truth in truckloads.
...but Powerline are the "wingnuts"?
Posted by Mitch at September 26, 2004 08:02 AM | TrackBack
Back when I would try to argue with these people, I would first attempt to unwind every one of their unfounded assertions, ad. h.'s, beggings of the question, etc. etc. By then I was too exhausted to continue and anyway the next response would repeat all of those and add still more. So I'd throw up my hands and they'd say, "Quitting the field, eh?"
Uh, yeah, I'm quitting the field. Tired of slipping in your blood. These people remind me of nobody more than the Black Knight of Holy Grail fame. Except less funny.
Posted by: Brian Jones at September 26, 2004 09:18 AMBrian, I feel yer pain.
I feel like the cops in "Rush", the undercover narcs who end up hoovering up their evidence; I started observing the leftyblogs this past week for purely comparative purposes. Maybe it's just something I need to work out of my system; maybe it's just that there's *so much material*, and it's so easy and irresistable...
Ooof. This election can't happen soon enough.
Posted by: myatch at September 26, 2004 09:23 AMIf you really want to wallow in lefty-dom, sign up for a unix shell account from panix.com (just $10/month!) and spend some time in the panix.chat newsgroup. 99% New Yorkers all suffering from classic groupthink. Time for me to dive back in for another round with them. cowabunga!
Posted by: eliza-beta at September 27, 2004 06:52 AM