shotbanner.jpeg

May 14, 2002

Strange Bedfellows - When regular

Strange Bedfellows - When regular people get together to talk about gun owners' rights, they discuss the practical aspects of the issue; "do guns in the hands of the law-abiding make us all safer"? It's an argument that the gun-rights movement has largely won, on the merits of a strong, unrefuted case.

When wonks gather to discuss the issue, it's more likely to turn to talk of is there really a right to keep and bear arms. There, the issue is both clearer and murkier. The Second Amendment is not a well-written piece of legislation, although a majority of our premier legal minds support the notion that the right to keep and bear arms is an individual, not group, right. Even pre-eminent constitutional scholar Laurence Tribe, after years of claiming the Amendment referred to a group right (the misunderstood "well-regulated militia"), changed his mind - largely on the strength of the reasoning of constitutional legal scholar Sanford Levinson.

Now, something I never believed I'd see in my lifetime - liberal antigun zealot Senator Chuckie Schumer has come out supporting the concept of the individual right.

The Berlin Wall falling in our lifetimes was nothing compared to this...

Posted by Mitch at May 14, 2002 12:42 PM
Comments
hi