Joe Doakes from Como Park writes re Keith Ellison’s letter to Hamas:
What, already? It’s only been 5 years. What’s the rush, Congressman?
And why such forceful action? Co-signing a letter to Hamas Leader-For-Now Khaled Mashaal, coming without warning, without any preliminary negotiation or preconditions, joined only by 11 other headline-seekers . . . that seems preemptory and a unilateral. Where is the international support?
But perhaps this letter is a signal of some strongly held belief? An act of fierce moral urgency? What, exactly, do you mean when you say:
“”It just seemed like a humane, decent thing to do,” Ellison said of sending the letter. “I don’t think [Shalit’s captivity is] helping the Palestinian people get a state, which I earnestly pray that they get. I think it hardens Israeli hearts and makes it more difficult to move the ball.”
Frankly, Congressman Ellison, it doesn’t sound as if you condemn the tactic of attacking Jews or taking hostages in principal, only that you think the tactic didn’t work out as planned in this particular instance, so you urge a different strategy.
You’ve gotta wonder.
I’ve told this story before; a few years ago, I appeared as a panelist on an internet talk show; Ellison was a guest.
I asked him if he repudiated the bits and pieces of the Hamas charter that called for the extinction of Israel and the extermination of the Jews – and by asked, I mean “with almost obsequious politeness”.
His response? “How many Palestinians do you know?”
I donate that insult to my intelligence to all of CD5’s voters with consciences.
Doakes:
I’m certain that’s a comfort to the people living in Israel to know that a junior Congressman from Minnesota signed a letter to the leader of an organization explicitly committed to the destruction of Israel, advising them to shift tactics to complete the Holocaust. Jews everywhere should sleep soundly tonight. The rest of us – especially those living in Minnesota’s Fourth Congressional District – should hang our heads in shame.
Joe Doakes
Como Park
Oh, I feel the shame.
But I’m not hanging my head. I’m raising my (rhetorical) fist.
Ellison is an embarassment.
This isn’t Goodwins law as the analogy it involves actual Nazis in the mideast.
Mr Lindbergh. Will you condemn the actions of the Hitler administration against the Jews.
How many Germans do you know?
I didn’t think it could get worse than Martin Sabo. I was wrong.
It’s too bad that the majority of his constituents are race baiting brain dead zombie members of the entitled class. He will never be voted out.
Congressperson-for-life Ellison thanks you for your interest. Now bugger off.
Mitch, you left out the most pertinent line from the Red Star’s article.
(“A letter like this is a shot in the dark,” Ahmed said, “and we can only hope it lands in the right place and touches someone’s heart.”)